Renewable Energy

MIT Study Ties Utility-Scale Solar to Lower US Power Prices, Rooftop Solar to Higher Ones

Naledi MokoenaOctober 13, 20265 min read9 views

At a glance

  • A state-utility panel from 1998 to 2023 finds renewable portfolio standards and utility-scale solar are not linked to higher residential electricity prices, while rooftop solar correlates with higher bills.
  • MIT CEEPR researchers report that US renewable portfolio standards and utility-scale renewables, especially utility-scale solar, are not associated with higher residential electricity prices, whereas rooftop solar correlates with higher prices and distribution costs. The authors stress the results are correlations and link the rooftop outcome to rate design and a grid not built for bidirectional flows.
Large ground-mounted solar panels beside transmission towers on the left, and suburban rooftops with small solar arrays on the right, linked by stylized power lines.

Researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology have found that renewable portfolio standards (RPS) and utility-scale renewables are not associated with higher residential electricity prices in the United States, while rooftop solar is linked to higher prices. The findings appear in "Renewables and Electricity Affordability: Untangling Correlation from Causation," published as MIT Center for Energy and Environmental Policy Research (CEEPR) Working Paper 2025-22 by Fischer J. Espiritu Argosino and Christopher R. Knittel.

The authors built a state-utility panel covering 1998 to 2023 that links residential prices, RPS stringency, generation mixes and utility spending, drawing on data from the US Energy Information Administration, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. That panel design lets the study compare how prices moved alongside changes in the renewable mix and in utility spending, rather than simply contrasting states with and without renewables.

What the regression found

Using a two-way fixed effects regression model that controls for unobserved differences across years and between states, the researchers reported that RPSs have virtually zero impact on residential prices, while utility-scale renewables are modestly associated with lower prices. Utility-scale solar stood out within that group.

Based on the paper's regression coefficients, which measure generation shares relative to coal, a 10-percentage-point rise in utility-scale solar's share of generation is associated with residential prices just over 8% lower. Rooftop solar moved the other way: a 5-percentage-point rise in its share of generation is associated with prices roughly 16% higher.

The authors cautioned that the results are correlations and said further work will apply "more rigorous econometric techniques to further strengthen the causal interpretation of these estimates." CEEPR does not peer-review working papers before posting them, so the study carries the status of a working paper rather than a peer-reviewed result.

Why utility-scale solar may lower costs

One explanation offered by the researchers is that large solar plants may reduce network congestion and place downward pressure on overall generation costs because they do not require fuel inputs. The cost advantage is tied to how these plants interact with the grid and to their fuel-free operation, not to any claim about rooftop systems.

A second model, which also controls for differences between utilities, found utility-scale solar strongly associated with lower transmission, distribution and total operation and maintenance (O&M) costs. That second specification matters because it holds utility-level characteristics constant, narrowing the comparison to how costs move within utilities as utility-scale solar grows.

Why rooftop solar correlates with higher prices

For the rooftop result, the researchers pointed to tariff design. "One possible reason for this is that current rate structures in some states shift fixed costs associated with rooftop solar from the owners onto other ratepayers," they said. "In effect, this means that those without rooftop solar often fund those who do through an additional volumetric rate."

The mechanism described is a cost shift: if fixed grid costs are recovered through volumetric charges, customers who install rooftop solar buy less electricity and therefore contribute less toward those fixed costs, leaving a larger share to be collected from other ratepayers.

Rooftop solar was also strongly correlated with higher distribution O&M costs. The researchers attributed this in part to grid architecture: "One reason for this is that the distribution network was not designed for bidirectional power flows." Distribution systems built for one-way delivery can require added investment when power also flows back from customer sites.

Context and an ongoing dispute

The utility-scale finding echoes a June 2025 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory study led by Ryan Wiser, which found that roughly 75% of US utility-scale wind and solar built outside RPS programs had no broadly discernible upward effect on retail prices. Together, the two results challenge the assumption that adding large-scale renewables necessarily pushes retail rates up.

The rooftop solar result feeds into a long-running dispute over cost-shifting in California. The California Public Utilities Commission's Public Advocates Office has estimated an $8.5 billion cost shift from rooftop solar customers to other ratepayers. A 2025 report by M.Cubed Consulting and the California Solar and Storage Association found instead that rooftop solar delivered a $1.5 billion net benefit to all California ratepayers. Solar advocates have also argued that rising transmission and distribution spending is a larger driver of rate increases. The MIT paper does not resolve that disagreement, but it adds regression evidence to one side of it while explicitly noting the limits of a correlational reading.

Policy implications

The researchers suggested that policymakers can secure an affordable energy future by improving the integration of low-cost renewables while implementing more equitable cost recovery strategies. That framing keeps the debate on two tracks: capturing the system-level cost benefits associated with large-scale solar, and reworking tariff structures so the fixed costs linked to rooftop solar are not shifted onto ratepayers who do not host it.

Because the estimates are correlations over a 1998-2023 US state-utility panel, they describe observed relationships rather than proven causes, and the authors flag stronger econometric work as a next step. The results also speak specifically to residential prices and utility cost categories in the United States, not to other markets or to system-wide cost effectiveness.

Reported by Naledi Mokoena, Power conversion and quality analyst.