Packaging & Printing

UK regulators set lower 2026 packaging evidence enforcement thresholds as FPA calls for 2027 review

Beatriz SalgadoOctober 18, 20265 min read5 views

At a glance

  • Regulatory position statements set reduced enforcement thresholds for plastic, steel and wood while the FPA warns that PRN/PERN supply and DRS changes undermine future targets.
  • UK regulators have said they will normally refrain from enforcement action against producers meeting lower 2026 thresholds for plastic, steel and wood packaging recycling evidence, after tighter accreditation and export rules constrained PRN/PERN supply. The FPA says the intervention exposes deeper problems and wants the 2027 targets reviewed to reflect DRS and delayed plastic-film collections.
Bales of plastic film, steel cans and wooden packaging sit in a clean warehouse, linked by blank documents and supply-chain lines to a recycling facility.

UK regulators have moved to address a shortfall in packaging recycling evidence by issuing Regulatory Position Statements that set reduced enforcement thresholds for three materials in the 2026 compliance year. The intervention follows tighter accreditation and enforcement rules that have reduced the availability of Packaging Waste Recycling Notes (PRNs) and Packaging Waste Export Recycling Notes (PERNs).

The statements were issued on 9 October after concerns that some producers and compliance schemes could struggle to demonstrate compliance with their 2026 recycling obligations. For plastic, steel and wood, regulators will not normally take enforcement action where businesses meet at least 83%, 92% and 90% of the statutory recycling obligations respectively. Full compliance remains required for all other packaging materials.

Relief does not change legal targets

The Environment Agency’s Regulatory Position Statement 383 makes clear that the statutory obligations have not been amended. Businesses that meet the RPS conditions will normally avoid enforcement action for missing the original targets in the three affected materials, but Certificates of Compliance will still record non-compliance where statutory obligations were not met. Companies relying on the RPS must keep supporting records for five years, meet full obligations for other materials and comply with all other applicable requirements. The intervention applies only to 2026.

Defra described the circumstances as exceptional. It said changes introduced during 2026—including stricter accreditation requirements for reprocessors and exporters, a new fit-and-proper-person test, more enforcement activity and revised export rules—had improved transparency and helped tackle fraud and error. However, those measures also reduced the number of accredited reprocessors and exporters and increased the time needed to issue PERNs, constraining the supply of recycling evidence. Under the revised export rules, PERNs can only be issued once packaging waste reaches the overseas reprocessing facility.

FPA warns of structural mismatch

The Foodservice Packaging Association said the need for regulatory intervention raises serious questions about how the system is managed and how future targets are set. It supported efforts to eliminate fraud and error, stronger accreditation, more rigorous verification and greater transparency, but argued that if integrity improvements expose a substantial shortfall in evidence, the assumptions behind recycling targets should be fundamentally examined.

The FPA also drew a distinction between relief from enforcement and resolving the underlying compliance problem. Statutory obligations remain unchanged, and producers meeting the reduced thresholds may still have non-compliance recorded against them. The association said businesses need clarity about the practical consequences.

Defra has committed to reviewing recycling targets for 2027, taking account of factors including the introduction of a deposit return scheme (DRS) and the delayed mandatory kerbside collection of plastic film in England. The FPA said the DRS impact will be particularly significant. From October 2027, in-scope PET plastic bottles and aluminium and steel drinks cans collected through the DRS will no longer generate PRNs or PERNs. That will remove valuable, relatively high-quality material from the existing evidence market even though it will continue to be recycled through the new scheme.

The delayed mandatory kerbside collection of plastic film in England, now scheduled for April 2030, adds another consideration when assessing the volume of material likely to be available for recycling and PRN generation. The FPA said the 2027 review must go beyond adjusting percentages and establish whether targets are supported by demonstrable domestic and overseas recycling capacity and reliable evidence supply. It also called for the DRS and plastic-film collection changes to be reflected in the calculations, and for the assessments to be transparent and open to industry scrutiny.

Longer-term reform of the PRN/PERN system remains under consideration following consultation on measures intended to improve transparency, reduce fraud and create a more level playing field between UK reprocessors and exporters. The FPA warned that producers are already facing financial and administrative pressure from the wider packaging reform programme and should not be exposed to unpredictable compliance costs caused by a mismatch between regulatory obligations and the evidence market. It said the test of the government’s response will be whether it delivers a more stable, credible and achievable system for 2027 and beyond.

Reported by Beatriz Salgado, Sustainable Packaging and Procurement Analyst.